| |

Solidarity you can screenshot isn’t solidarity 
In a generation fluent in “bed-rotting” and “doom-scrolling,” even empathy gets treated as too much effort.

It takes less than a second of “activism” to tap the heart, type a comment, hit repost and keep scrolling. Scroll through TikTok or Instagram, or any post from a Palestinian Aid Organization, and you’ll find someone asking for something real—period products for displaced women and girls; food for children and formula for babies; an emergency birth kit; funds for a medical treatment only available abroad. But scroll down to the comment section and you’ll notice a particular disconnect: a wave of “hearts,” a chain of comments responding to “What’s your favourite colour? Answer below” or “Sending love!!” or even more recently, just a repost.

The gap between what posts are asking, even begging, of viewers to do and what the comment section gives is where performative activism lives. “Performative” is a word that gets thrown around until it means nothing, so I want to be specific. I don’t mean people who do things in small, perhaps imperfect action. What I mean is the increasingly common move of converting someone’s grief and the desperation for that grief to be recognized into a repackaged opportunity to perform a moral highness—actions that cost nothing but leave people feeling like they did something.

Commenting doesn’t create change the way a donation page does, or a phone call to representatives, educating your friends, or even a conversation with the person running the account does. People move from one post to the next, and the next, and the next.

Recently, rapper Macklemore posted a lengthy statement about a difficult conversation with Ed Sheeran, the cost of choosing a side and speaking out in support of Palestine. He was removed from the Sheeran Loop Tour by promoters and venue owners, and in response, donated $1 million in earnings from the Tour to six different Palestinian Aid Organizations, including the Palestine Children’s Relief Fund, HEAL Palestine, Gaza Soup Kitchen, Medical Aid for Palestinians, UNRWA USA National Committee Inc. and Anera Org. 

Compare that to the hundreds of thousands of people who reposted the news of the split, the screenshots, fan art, and “this is so crazy” captions on their stories. Reposting a 24-hour story of someone else’s statement, actions, and donations is not the same as making your own. It’s possible to circulate the righteous statement on the internet and still walk away having spent nothing, risked nothing, and changed nothing. 

The same thing applies much closer to home than celebrity drama. The friend who attends every protest, chants loudly, and supports protesters at the encampment, then checks out of grocery stores without reading labels, picking up her daily coffee from a boycotted chain on the way home. A boycott, unlike a march, actually asks something of you: a change in habit, a small daily inconvenience, going to a different coffee shop, giving something up.

I’ve learned a lot about my friendships by reflecting on just how pervasive performative activism is today—especially in regards to Palestine. I had one friend who I would sit with for hours and talk—sometimes even cry to—about missing my family in Palestine. I explained to her what an occupation is, or why I haven’t visited home in nearly 10 years. The next day she’d ask to hang out and get McDonald’s, because it’s just two-dollar fries and then proceed to ask, is a boycott even productive?

Then I meet a new friend who asks tone-deaf questions, like “why can’t you guys try to live peacefully?” Questions about decades of occupation that become “not deep” and “just a hypothetical,” to implicitly place the burden of “peace” on the people waiting and surveilled at checkpoints, not the armed forces building and enforcing them.

I used to be confused about why the friends I invited to the October 7th protests around campus seemed embarrassed to be there. One even laughed and recorded the crowd to share with his friends—new side quest unlocked, I guess. It takes surprisingly little, apparently, for people to stop caring once their Palestinian friend leaves the room. 

I grew up outside of Palestine, raised on stories of martyrs and raids from family and the Al Jazeera channel my parents kept on 24/7. I learned about displacement and occupation at a young age. I also learned the hard way not to bring up the Palestinian experience in school the day the news broke that Mohammed Abu Khdeir, a 16-year-old boy from Al-Quds, was kidnapped outside a mosque by settlers, forced to drink gasoline and burned to death in a nearby forest. It wasn’t a school-appropriate topic to bring up for indoor recess. 

Now, I can talk freely about the treatment of Palestinians, the genuine grief expressed and then too often left there. I’ve gone to the protests, the charity events, and had the same difficult conversations with friends that leave us as strangers. 

That’s why conversations about performative activism feel more urgent than ever. We know that real activism demands us to reconsider our friendships and relationships—and in the process—risk loss and estrangement. Performative activism, made easier than ever through our digitally connected lives, may make you feel better and even give you a sense of purpose. But, who does that purpose really serve? The self-assumed moral superiority we feel—especially with Palestine—does not add anything to the movement we claim to be building or the people whose liberation we claim to champion. 

Activism is more than sharing a post with a link in bio. It’s the unglamorous work of checking in on your friends through difficult conversations, boycotting a brand you might have nostalgic attachments to, and hardest of all, to stay true to one’s moral and political convictions unwaveringly. Show some humanity to people grieving loved ones. I can’t fix the checkpoints. I can’t comment my way into pretending it creates change. But I can tell you to stop pretending to show up and start actually doing it.


*AI-Generated Audio Transcription Disclaimer

The audio transcription included in this article was generated using artificial intelligence (AI) technology with the purpose of improving accessibility for our readers and providing an alternative opportunity to engage with The Medium‘s content. Please note that AI-generated transcriptions may contain errors or inaccuracies in pronunciation, wording, or interpretation.

The original written article remains the authoritative version of the content. If you notice an error in the audio transcription, please contact social@themedium.ca so we can conduct further reviews and corrections.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *