Reconciliation is (re)colonization.
Canadian reconciliatory politics are a mirage to erase hopes of decolonization.
Listen to the audio version of this article here!*
Canadian reconciliatory politics are politics of coloniality.
The constitutional independence of Canada was marked in 1982 by the Constitution Act. Practically presented in the form of a footnote, the Act was accompanied by a new political framework that entrenched Indigenous recognition into the law: “the existing aboriginal and treaty rights of aboriginal peoples of Canada are hereby recognised and affirmed.”
Perhaps to the Government of Canada, Section 25 of the Act was an oath of reconciliation, but to no avail, it has manifested as an empty constitutional promise to manage settler-colonial guilt. Most glaringly, the politics of reconciliation have reduced Indigenous Peoples as a radical minority on their own lands—and among other blatant issues, Canadian reconciliatory politics are fundamentally faulty because it still treats the land as a materialistic claim. Hence, I find it difficult to reason with the passiveness and ridicule of reconciliation, despite what official documents and national leaders pledge to commit themselves to.
Earlier this year in March, members of Asubpeeschoseewagong Netum Anishinabek, the Grassy Narrows First Nation, protested on Parliament Hill. Their demands were clear: to seek justice from the Government of Canada. In the 1960s, the Dryden Paper Mill (or the Reed Mill), in collaboration with the Canadian government, committed a genocidal target against the Grassy Narrows First Nation when the English-Wabigoon River was poisoned by mercury, contaminating the livelihood of the Nation. Today, 90 per cent of the Grassy Narrows’ still suffer from mercury poisoning.
Chrissy Isaacs, a member of Grassy Narrows, is among the many affected. In March, she was also among the many redirecting the focus of a housing conference, attended by Prime Minister Mark Carney and Ontario Premier Doug Ford, towards the Grassy Narrows’ crisis. When her voice reached Carney, he arrogantly responded with, “I can outlast her.” It was a mockery of Isaacs’ health issues that persist as a result of the Canadian government’s negligence and he has yet to apologize for the comment.
Beyond the impudence that comes with mockery, Carney’s comment is proof that Indigenous outrage—a rightful response to colonialism—is policed and politicized. In his book Red Skin, White Masks: Rejecting the Colonial Politics of Recognition (2014), Glen Sean Coulthard notes that Indigenous resentment is often linked to an “inability or an unwillingness to get over the past.” That is precisely the attitude that Carney presumes. As Coulthard claims, this is because the Canadian government—and by association, Carney—fails to dignify the consciousness of Indigenous Peoples. Indigenous resentment is seen as a social ill with roots that are “too far to trace back to.”
In that, I see that Carney is the living breath of coloniality, where coloniality is the control of knowledge and the byproduct of colonialism. I initially considered claiming that he is “the legacy of coloniality,” but colonialism is an active project on Turtle Island today. Nevertheless, much like the colonial institutions that preceded the Canadian government, Carney lives under the premises that his rule, the colonial rule, will endure eternally. But history chimes in curious ways. So, much like the colonial institutions that preceded the Canadian government, his too will cease to exist one day.
Hence why I claim Canadian reconciliatory politics is a politics of coloniality. Because despite the promises, Canada nestles itself comfortably in the arms of colonialism—a comfort that settles well enough for its leader to mock the livelihood of Indigenous Peoples to a televised conference. What reconciliatory politics inevitably do is create a myth that Indigenous Peoples’ recognition is a catalyst for “peace.” In reality, it is merely a mirage to erase hopes of decolonization.
Perhaps what is most frustrating is that the Canadian government’s recognition of Indigenous Peoples (a bare minimum) teeters into “misrecognition,” a misrepresented view of what Indigenous Peoples’ rights are. In return, the colonial tactic of “unrecognition” is produced. Or in other words, Indigenous Peoples are stripped of their autonomy, livelihood, and existence through federal oaths and signed treaties that are violated before the ink dries.
I go back to what I claimed earlier: Canadian reconciliatory politics are fundamentally faulty because they still treat the land as a materialistic claim. The problem is the land. It has always been about the land. I cannot grasp the idea of reconciliation as mending relations between the colonized and colonizers when the land remains occupied, commodified, and exploited. I do not mean this in the physical ownership of the land. No, the land occupied is an occupation against the Indigenous Peoples’ rights of living with the land. In the same vein, land occupation is the direct product of Carney’s audacious mockery. This is why it is an absurdity to frame reconciliation as a solution for the genocide, occupation, erasure, crimes, and horror inflicted by and for the ongoing colonial project.
Beyond the tangible abuses of reconciliation, Canadian reconciliatory politics also reduce Indigeneity to the identity and politics of victimhood. Reconciliation depends on the concept of Indigenous sufferance. That is not to say that colonialism does not produce identities of victimhood. But Indigeneity exists beyond pain and loss—and it is reconciliation that manipulates the national memory of Indigenous Peoples to keep them perpetually homeless and disenfranchised on their own land.
As a history student and an indigenous person of a former colony, I find myself distrusting of the Canadian government’s intentions with Indigenous politics. I do not find comfort in the supposedly well-intended promises that are spewed at Indigenous communities, whilst their demands are mocked and their livelihood is reduced to ridicule. I find many discomforts in my lecture halls, when decolonization and resistance are discussed as theoretical ideas, judged and weighed by measures that mean little to me. But in the philosophies of Indigenous Peoples, I find the voice of all indigenous peoples.
In his concluding thoughts, Coulthard writes that “it is only by privileging and grounding ourselves in these normative [Indigenous] lifeways and resurgent practices that we have hope of surviving our strategic engagements with the colonial state, with integrity and as Indigenous Peoples.”
*AI-Generated Audio Transcription Disclaimer
The audio transcription included in this article was generated using artificial intelligence (AI) technology with the purpose of improving accessibility for our readers and providing an alternative opportunity to engage with The Medium‘s content. Please note that AI-generated transcriptions may contain errors or inaccuracies in pronunciation, wording, or interpretation.
The original written article remains the authoritative version of the content. If you notice an error in the audio transcription, please contact social@themedium.ca so we can conduct further reviews and corrections.
Copy Editor (Volume 53) — Greetings, everyone! I am Yasmine Benabderrahmane and I am delighted to join The Medium’s Volume 53 as one of your Copy Editors. I am currently a History graduate student at the University of Toronto, specialising in decolonial African history. As a former staff writer, Associate Opinion Editor, and V52’s Opinion Editor, I am honoured to continue to be part of a community that upholds the journalistic integrity of student voices. In my spare time, you might catch me starting (and never finishing) crochet projects, hiking with my camera, or reading.

