When reconciliation calls for reform: is the abolishment of the Indian Act a complete solution?
The debate around outdated legislation is nuanced, but the rights of those impacted should be undeniably clear.

There exists a variety of legislation from decades past within Canada—after all, it’s what the foundation of the country has been built on. But this then begs the question: what should be done when those documents neither assimilate nor allow for the sovereignty of a people? The answer lies not in complete abolition, but rather purposeful and actionable reforms that result in concrete change.

The Indian Act, originally established in 1876, has become a widely debated piece of legislation not only between the Canadian government and Indigenous communities, but even within these communities themselves. Many different agreements and treaties rely on the Indian Act in order for Indigenous communities to retain rights and claim to their land, and yet there have been calls for decades to abolish it to varying extents due to its discriminatory nature.

More recently, there have been calls by members of government to abolish the Indian Act, although this has also been met with disapproval from the Indigenous community themselves. Premier Wab Kinew called for the abolition of the Indian Act recently, being met with support from Prime Minister Mark Carney; the issue in this lies in the complete abolishment of this legislature. Not only does this rid these communities of many of the agreements that they rely on to preserve their rights and ownership, but without it there would be a far more lacking system in which Indigenous communities would have access to far less.

Abolishment is not so straightforward, however; the Indian Act was fully redrafted and repealed in 1951, but even then the issue remains that there exists a clear divide left in great parts unaddressed by the federal government. There are numerous issues that are even more highly prioritized by Indigenous communities, such as safe access to basic human resources and the ownership of native lands, which have rightfully become more pressing than tackling legal documents. But this does not mean that it is of no importance.

While the Canadian government no longer supports the open and aggressive assimilation of Indigenous communities as it once did, existing laws and ongoing actions still push for the passive assimilation of the Indigenous Peoples, and much of the current efforts towards reconciliation are no different from this. 

On September 21, our Federal Government, led by Prime Minister Mark Carney, introduced the sweeping omnibus Bill C-39. Titled the “Building Canada Strong Act,” Bill C-39 has faced significant opposition from Indigenous leaders, environmental leaders, worker unions, and everyday Canadians for its proposition to accelerate major infrastructure projects supposedly in our best national interests. Under this Act, specific geographic areas could be designated for faster project developments, and legally bypass regulatory processes that were put in place to consider how developments could impact the environment and nearby communities—many of which are home to First Nations communities. 

For instance, if passed into law, Bill C-39 would allow our government to modify conditions of the “Species at Risk Act” and the “Fisheries Act” if they are deemed too financially or technically difficult. Because many proposed projects sit near sensitive lands, Indigenous groups, such as the Nishnawbe Aski Nation, warn of significant damage to sacred habitats, waterways, and to traditional harvesting rituals. 

Even more, Bill C-39 views regulatory timelines, independent review panels, and environmental protections as barriers to progress when it comes to fast-tracking pipelines, powerlines, and offshore energy projects. While our government and cabinet ministers argue that this omnibus bill is necessary for attracting investments and building a resilient economy—especially in light of the instability posed by the Trump administration—we, as the people and allies of those most vulnerable to the Bill’s changes, must ask: whose “national interests” is Bill C-39 serving? 

The Indian Act, as Premier Kinew rightly points out, is an outdated and discriminatory legislation. But as our government pushes forward with Bill C-39, we must consider the possibility that this Bill is the much larger and immediate threat to Indigenous sovereignty and justice in our country. True reconciliation begins when there is respect and fair treatment of Indigenous communities as we would any other peoples within our country, not as analogous to all other Canadian citizens, but to recognize their independent culture and place power in the hands of the people directly affected.

Unfortunately, this comes with a few hurdles. Indigenous lands are not always connected, making contemporary methods of marking borders more complex, particularly in regards to full sovereign independence from another country. Canada may have once been a British- and French-colony, but it was a distinctly separate land, and thus was far easier to label and border once it became independent. Again, a far more pressing matter are the lives and resources at stake within Indigenous communities, which is undoubtedly a series of issues that must first be amended and prevented in order for reconciliation to actually take place.

A notable stance, one I find myself agreeing with, is that the Indian Act guarantees sacred rights despite its discriminatory nature. Should the government of Canada truly and entirely repeal it, and put forth new agreements to treat the Indigenous peoples as equals with equal rights, they must first recognize that the Indian Act is not a good piece of legislation, and make amends by introducing more civilized agreements rather than replacing it with another Act.

In this case, reform may very well be the best option. In the end, of course, it would ideally result in new laws and documents barely comparable to the Indian Act we know today, but this method of abolition would be achieved through intentional reworking of the current agreements in place, and importantly, in consultation with First Nation communities.

As it stands, members of the Indigenous community are often still identified by their own unique identification documents (such as status cards), the likes of which we would and have not distributed to any other group within Canada’s demographic. So why them? Despite progress having been made in multiple regards, discrimination and stigma towards Indigenous issues is still deeply rooted in modern society, and we need to develop a more equitable system in order to truly coexist and benefit from collaboration between the Canadian government and Indigenous peoples.

These issues also occur not just within Canada, but internationally as well. South Africa faced similar issues surrounding discriminatory legislation put into place by settlers, with financial settlements being made to certain individuals who faced abuse, although many still remain unaddressed both financially and in regards to the destruction of their culture that they faced.

When we consider what’s at stake for these communities, it becomes paramount that more action is needed to remedy the harm faced by Indigenous Peoples at the hands of government and religious institutions. The debate surrounding how the Indian Act should be addressed and changed has existed for decades, now coming to the forefront once more as Carney’s political agenda blurs the lines between nation-building and exploitation. Complete abolishment not only ignores the agreements in place, but dedicates an invaluable amount of time that should instead be directed towards fighting against Bill C-39 and its potentially disastrous impacts on land, community, and the future of Canada’s working-class. 

In order to reconcile with the treatment of Indigenous communities as less deserving, we must first show respect and rights befitting those who are inarguably just as deserving of equal rights and independent identities, and that begins with the reformation of legislation like the Indian Act. Only then can true reconciliation be made.


*AI-Generated Audio Transcription Disclaimer

The audio transcription included in this article was generated using artificial intelligence (AI) technology with the purpose of improving accessibility for our readers and providing an alternative opportunity to engage with The Medium‘s content. Please note that AI-generated transcriptions may contain errors or inaccuracies in pronunciation, wording, or interpretation.

The original written article remains the authoritative version of the content. If you notice an error in the audio transcription, please contact social@themedium.ca so we can conduct further reviews and corrections.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *